To Talk or Not to Talk

Copy and opinion editor Elisabeth Andrews talks about whether participation grades are fair for people who are more introverted or have anxiety

More stories from Elisabeth Andrews

Growing up the youngest in a big family meant that it was always loud. Very loud. I don’t remember much from when I was a kid, but I do remember preferring to listen to my family talk instead of chiming in myself. I would listen to them playfully argue at Christmas and we’d spend hours playing board games because we wouldn’t stop talking.

There weren’t many participation grades when I attended middle school; my main problem was presentations. I would get so nervous that I would have to mumble and stutter my way through it. Something about standing in front of the entire class, everyone’s eyes on me and being graded on how well I did scared me, and I ended up getting worse grades not for the content I presented, but for my poise.

As an introvert, when I was first introduced to seminars and simulations in high school, all I could feel was panic. It was impossible for me to turn to someone and ask to be their partner in a simulation we were doing. In a seminar, about half the class would sit in a circle and talk about a topic the teacher gave us pertaining to a book or movie we had just finished, and we would be graded on how much we said and what we said. In these seminars, I found it hard to get a word in. When my teachers would ask the class how they felt about the passage we just read, my head would be full of words but I wasn’t able to raise my hand and voice them. I was stuck for a long time and my grades suffered for it. I thought that it was unfair that so much of my grades depended on talking in front of the class. It was easier for me to voice my opinion in a worksheet or an essay, but it was obvious that this was the way things were going to go, and I just had to accept that. There wasn’t any other option for me; it was either change or let my grades suffer.

Change isn’t an easy thing. Not for me, and I don’t think for anyone. I forced myself to join things that I normally wouldn’t be comfortable doing. I joined newspaper, tech crew for theatre and became a volunteer for Mrs. Isaac in the library doing circulation. I put myself in situations where it was a necessity to speak up. For a while, my heart would pound when I had to interview someone or when someone came up to check out a book at the library. I would still hesitate before raising my hand to voice my opinion in class, but it eventually became easier.

It happened so slowly I didn’t even notice it. I could stand up in front of a class by myself and my voice wouldn’t quiver. I wasn’t afraid when a teacher called my name in class. When someone would come up and check out a book, I would talk to them about it if it was a series that I liked. Being in a seminar was suddenly fun and something that I looked forward to.
I still have introverted qualities: I still like to stay silent and listen when there is a huge conversation going on, and I prefer to stay home than hang out every day after school with my friends. Now it is possible to speak up in a class and it is something I want to do, and my grades have gotten better. That’s all that matters, right?

For some people, participating in a seminar isn’t that big of a deal, but I had to change and put myself through many anxiety-raising situations. I look back at myself freshman year and I’m proud of who I am today, but I hate that had to change just to do better academically. I used to not get why simulations and seminars were such a big deal and why they were done so much. Yet, as time went on and I got through my anxiety, I realized how fun they were. Simulations I did in Mr. Dan Mastrovito’s classes are now some of my favorite memories. Talking about a book I really enjoy in a seminar or a class discussion is now something I look forward to in Mrs. Laura Liamini’s class. I get why we’re graded on these situations and why we do them in classes. I think teachers genuinely love to hear our responses and want to teach us something in a different style than just a lecture. I now know that teachers aren’t doing it just to be harsh, but that they are doing it to better our learning experiences. Isn’t that what we want from every teacher?